FRAGRANCES (1,931)
GROOMING TOOLS AND SPA (20,153)
HAIR CARE (5,676)
PERSONAL CARE (6,774)
SKIN CARE (8,538)
Shop Now At Walmart
Most Popular Products
Top-Rated Products
Customer Reviews for Maybelline Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
Maybelline Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
The Maybelline Line Works liquid eyeliner comes with a flexible tip for mistake proof control. It glides on the corner of your eyelids without smudging or smearing. This waterproof liquid eyeliner stays on your eyelids throughout the day until you take it off. The Maybelline liquid eyeliner dries up easily and goes well with your eye shadow to accentuate your eyes. You can swim, bathe, or cry with the mistake proof eyeliner on your eyes.
Average Customer Rating:
4.3
out of 5
(31 Reviews) 28
Rating SnapshotOverall Rating Totals
Customer Recommendation90%28 out of 31reviewers would recommend this product to a friend.
Rating SnapshotOverall Rating Totals
Customer Reviews
Review 1 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
I wouldnt recomend it
,04/30/2012
By iRate33 ,
fresno, Ca
1
out of
5
This liquid eyeliner was good at first but after a few weeks it stopped working as well. After that it was as if i was applying water to my eyelids because the liquid eyeliner wouldnt stick. I bought another one and i had the same problem. Because of this i wouldnt recommend this anymore. I now use L'oreal Telescopic liquid eyeliner which is much better.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
2
out of
5
Value for price paid
4
out of
5
Color appeal
5
out of
5
Value
3
out of
5
Quality
3
out of
5
Recommends this product? No
Age:18 - 24
Gender:Female
Ownership:2 - 7 weeks
Usage:Every few days
0points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 2 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
It's perfect!
,05/03/2013
By Damys ,
LBK
5
out of
5
Finally i found the best of eyeliners!!!
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
5
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:25 - 34
Gender:Female
Ownership:2 - 7 weeks
Usage:Every few days
0points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 3 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
Best liquid eyeliner!
,02/27/2013
By rbj1209 ,
Northern Virginia
5
out of
5
This is the only liquid eyeliner that works for me and doesn't smudge.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
5
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:25 - 34
Gender:Female
Ownership:Longer than one year
Usage:Every day
0points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 4 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
12/15/2012
By ahigr ,
pooler, ga.
5
out of
5
works great makes my eys look bautiful
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
5
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:65 or older
Gender:Female
Ownership:1 week or less
Usage:Every day
0points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 5 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
Best Eyeliner EVER
,07/08/2012
By ASMB2685 ,
Edgewood, KY
5
out of
5
I am an eyeliner junky. This is the best I've found so far. It is so easy to use and the color is great. Most importantly, it stays on forever!!! I get the waterproof version and this is the only drawback, it will run in the pool or shower. LOVE LOVE this eyeliner!!!
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
5
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:25 - 34
Gender:Female
Ownership:Longer than one year
Usage:Every day
0points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 6 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
Easy to apply and stays on all day!
,06/15/2012
By jzwick ,
Tacoma, WA
5
out of
5
This eyeliner was exactly the one I was looking for. So good to have it shipped right to my mail box in just a few days.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
5
out of
5
Value for price paid
5
out of
5
Color appeal
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
5
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:45 - 54
Gender:Female
Ownership:2 - 7 weeks
Usage:Every few days
0points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 7 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
Can't go wrong with this eye liner
,06/06/2012
By XMichX
5
out of
5
This is one of the best liquid eye liners out there! I've always preferred felt tip to a brush since it's much easier to control. Plus, liquid eye liners stay on much longer than pencil eye liners. I've tried several other liquid eye liners from L'Oreal, Covergirl, etc... and all of them would eventually begin to flake off in pieces throughout the day and either fall into your eye or get stuck in your eye lashes. This eye liner has never once did that to me and I've been using it for years now! It doesn't run or smudge either. It's waterproof too which is great. It can hold up to tears, sweat, and general eye-watering pretty well but it will come off if you go swimming but then again I haven't found an eye liner that doesn't. Overall, this is a great product and definitely worth a try for anyone who hasn't used it yet.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
4
out of
5
Value for price paid
5
out of
5
Color appeal
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
5
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:18 - 24
Gender:Female
Ownership:Longer than one year
Usage:Every day
0points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 8 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
Love it, but definitely NOT waterproof
,04/21/2012
By Yalie ,
Washington, DC
4
out of
5
This is an excellent eyeliner. Goes on very opaque and it's very easy to use. My only issue is that it's not really waterproof. If you get caught in the rain or a sweaty workout, it's gonna run. Still probably worth it for the price though.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
5
out of
5
Value for price paid
5
out of
5
Color appeal
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
4
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:25 - 34
Gender:Female
Ownership:2 - 7 weeks
Usage:Every day
0points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 9 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
great eyeliner
,03/06/2012
By Valle83 ,
vannuys,ca
5
out of
5
Its great to use & easy to apply to your eyes.i highly recommend it.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
5
out of
5
Value for price paid
5
out of
5
Color appeal
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
5
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:25 - 34
Gender:Female
Ownership:1 week or less
Usage:Every few days
0points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 10 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
03/01/2012
By MauiLuv ,
California
4
out of
5
This liquid eyeliner is the best I've found! The tip is perfect for being precise (not too thin or thick & isn't angled to make it more awkward like others) and it is easy to apply. The liner does not crack during the day, it stays on for at least 15 hours! The ONLY down side to this (which is why I gave it 4 stars instead of 5), even being waterproof (it's not waterproof, it easily comes off in water) if you have greasy eyelids at all or its a hot or humid day, it will come off on your upper eyelid, not completely, mainly on the outer corners so it will need to be retouched a couple times a day if you have that issue but besides that, even if you do have that, it is the best and lasts months even being used daily!
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
4
out of
5
Value for price paid
5
out of
5
Color appeal
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
5
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:25 - 34
Gender:Female
Ownership:Longer than one year
Usage:Every day
0points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 11 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
01/30/2012
By makeupqueen37814
5
out of
5
Review 12 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
Probably not the best for beginners...
,12/06/2011
By MW14
3
out of
5
I'm very new to using liquid eyeliner and that definitely could have been the problem. I didn't think that the liner was outstanding, but it did work pretty well, and it was a really good deal. The tip was pretty good. My main issues were that it ran out of liner very fast which made application harder than usual.
If you have some experience with liquid eyeliner you could probably make this work no problem, it just wasn't the best for me as a beginner.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
1
out of
5
Value for price paid
5
out of
5
Color appeal
4
out of
5
Value
3
out of
5
Quality
3
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:18 - 24
Gender:Female
Ownership:2 - 7 weeks
Usage:A few times per month
0points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 13 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
I love this eyeliner!
,10/26/2011
By an anonymous customer
4
out of
5
I used to use liquid eyeliner on a daily basis, but I recently switched to pencil though. When I did use liquid everyday though, I would use this! It is amazing! It's EXTREMELY waterproof, it doesn't smudge, and it doesn't burn if you put it under your lashes on your upper lid. I absolutely adore this! My one complaint would be that it is a bit difficult to take off before bed, even with makeup remover, but other than that, it's amazing! Deffinately a great buy!
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
3
out of
5
Value for price paid
4
out of
5
Color appeal
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
4
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
+6points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 14 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
You Should Buy It
,07/03/2011
By Whit789 ,
ND
5
out of
5
This stuff is great. It goes on pretty easily and even though it's waterproof, if you make a mistake, it still comes right off with water. And after you put it on, it stays all day. I have never had any smears with this eyeliner.
Great price too.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
5
out of
5
Value for price paid
5
out of
5
Color appeal
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
4
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:18 - 24
Gender:Female
Ownership:2 - 7 weeks
Usage:Every few days
+3points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 15 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
Awesome Eyeliner
,06/05/2011
By cartist515 ,
Michigan
5
out of
5
This is my favorite eyeliner ever and when I go to the store to buy it, the shelf is always wiped out because so many people buy it. (At least I would like to think that way) So when I found it on Walmart.com I was excited and bought four of them.
The eyeliner stays on all day and really is waterproof and the applicator is really easy to use. Definitely try this product you won't be disappointed.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
5
out of
5
Value for price paid
5
out of
5
Color appeal
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
5
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:25 - 34
Gender:Female
Ownership:2 - 7 weeks
Usage:Every day
+9points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 16 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
One of the best
,03/17/2011
By EveryoneHasAnickname
5
out of
5
I prefer liquid or gel liners over pencils.
1.This is one of the best when it comes to wear and it does not crack like maybellines stiletto liner-that one is awful.
2.This is one is good for lining the bottom eyelid.
3.The felt tip is NOT soft and flexible so it makes it so easy to draw lines especially is you are a beginner. Tip is a little like a pencil.
4.This liner is NOT so great with the waterproof aspect but it does not concern me because i just need a liner that stays on for long without starting to look crazy after an hour or two.
I'm sad that it's discontinued so I will be stocking up.
1.This is one of the best when it comes to wear and it does not crack like maybellines stiletto liner-that one is awful.
2.This is one is good for lining the bottom eyelid.
3.The felt tip is NOT soft and flexible so it makes it so easy to draw lines especially is you are a beginner. Tip is a little like a pencil.
4.This liner is NOT so great with the waterproof aspect but it does not concern me because i just need a liner that stays on for long without starting to look crazy after an hour or two.
I'm sad that it's discontinued so I will be stocking up.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
5
out of
5
Value for price paid
5
out of
5
Color appeal
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
5
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:18 - 24
+19points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 17 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
I LOVE THIS SO MUCH!!
,03/03/2011
By makeuplover26
5
out of
5
This is my favorite eyeliner of all the time!! And it is the only one that works for lining the inside of my eyelid!! I have tried manyyy other brand names and alot more expensive brands, but nothing works for lining the inside of my eye. all other eyeliners have tips that are the flimsy brush kind so they go all over when i try to line inside my eye, or other ones that also have a felt tip like this one, are either too soft and messy to use or too hard and poke my eye. This one has the BEST and easiest applicator to use to line inside my eye.
The formula is also reallyyyy long-lasting, has NEVER smudged or ran on me!!! It is indeed waterproof, sweatproff, etc. I've had it on all day-long /all night-long through clubbing whatever, it stays put all night!! I def recommend this!!!
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
5
out of
5
Value for price paid
5
out of
5
Color appeal
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
5
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:18 - 24
Gender:Female
Ownership:Longer than one year
Usage:Every day
+2points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 18 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
Worst "waterproof" liquid liner ever
,12/30/2010
By OneSavvyChick
1
out of
5
I used this product years ago and had nothing but great things to say about it until now because they changed their formula. This item is supposed to be waterproof, but it's such a joke. With just one tiny droplet of water, this stuff will instantly run down your face like a sad clown. Even if you don't get water on your eyes, it will smudge and wear off of oily eyelids so easily. I have to return this in-store soon. And now I need to find a new favorite waterproof liquid eyeliner.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
4
out of
5
Value for price paid
2
out of
5
Color appeal
3
out of
5
Value
1
out of
5
Quality
2
out of
5
Recommends this product? No
Age:18 - 24
Gender:Female
0points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 19 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
10/18/2010
By MamaStukey ,
USA
5
out of
5
love love LOVE this! i was kind of hesitant because of the price, i normally will not spend more than a couple bucks on eyeliner, but i've been noticing that makeup isn't the cheapest anymore, and it definitely lasts awhile. i've used different liquid liners before and have had issues with getting it applied evenly, but the applicator on it isn't a brush, it's more stiff and makes it sooo much easier. drys fast and looks great, will buy again!
i was also impressed with the shipping results, i had all my products within a few days, just by selecting standard, the cheapest shipping.
i was also impressed with the shipping results, i had all my products within a few days, just by selecting standard, the cheapest shipping.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
5
out of
5
Value for price paid
5
out of
5
Color appeal
5
out of
5
Value
5
out of
5
Quality
5
out of
5
Recommends this product? Yes
Age:18 - 24
Gender:Female
Ownership:2 - 7 weeks
Usage:Every few days
+2points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.
Review 20 for Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner, Black 451
terrible, never again!!
,08/19/2010
By nvfdv05 ,
NC
1
out of
5
At first the liner seemed perfect, it went on real smooth, the color was great and the line stayed on for hours without fading.. BUT THEN I noticed this liner has a habit of cracking after a few hours. Bad quality. It's easily fixed if that doesn't bother you, just go over it again. The worst part comes the next day, IT NEVER COMES OFF! I'll admit, maybe I'm doing something wrong, but this thing sticks to your eyelashes and literally doesn't come off not even with liquid remover. It hurts to peel it off, (yes, peel off cuz nothing else works) your eyes and eyelashes look kinda crazy for a few days until it all rubs off. Ugh, what a hassle. I use it only as a last resort. I'm currently searching for a better brand.
Product Attributes:
Ease of use
2
out of
5
Value for price paid
2
out of
5
Color appeal
2
out of
5
Value
1
out of
5
Quality
1
out of
5
Recommends this product? No
Gender:Female
Ownership:3 - 4 months
Usage:A few times per month
-5points
Thank you! You have successfully submitted a comment for this review.